String with clipped pictures and woman in white long-sleeve shirt holding printer paper.
String with clipped pictures and woman in white long-sleeve shirt holding printer paper.
Home /Legacybox / ScanMyPhotos Review: How Does It Compare to Legacybox?

ScanMyPhotos Review: How Does It Compare to Legacybox?

Share
By Kellie Hillis

Photo digitization promises peace of mind. This is your chance to convert physical media to a digital format — keeping precious pictures looking pristine far into the future.

 

Good news: getting your photos digitized has never been easier. Many services promise to take the hard work off your hands so you can focus on enjoying treasured memories.

 

As you explore available digitizing services, a unique name may catch your eye: ScanMyPhotos. It's easy to see what this company promises — it's all in the name. ScanMyPhotos has much to offer, including quick and affordable digitizing services. Still, it's natural to wonder: how does ScanMyPhotos stack up against Legacybox?

 

There's a lot to consider, but a quick look at available services and price points should help. Keep reading to learn more about ScanMyPhotos and how it compares to Legacybox's digitization services.

 

ScanMyPhotos Overview

Launched in Irvine, California, ScanMyPhotos was born as Mitch Goldstone and Carl Berman noticed major tech-driven changes in the photography space. They chose to bring their business online, focusing on bulk photo scanning services.

 

Today, ScanMyPhotos is known for providing a simple and straightforward approach to photo digitization. This company has a solid reputation, backed by a long history of success in photo scanning and beyond.

 

Legacybox Overview

As a big name in the media digitization space, Legacybox has become a real trailblazer with help from cutting-edge solutions. Visionaries Adam Boeselager and Nick Macco worked together to find an easy way to preserve precious memories. Their efforts paid off, and today, customers are thrilled with Legacybox's quality conversions.

 

Launched in a renovated garage but now boasting a state-of-the-art facility in Chattanooga, Tennessee, Legacybox commands attention with high-quality scans, video transfers, and other services. This company is known for its tech-forward options. Another perk? An intuitive approach that makes media easy and enjoyable to preserve.

 

Head-to-Head Comparison: ScanMyPhotos vs. Legacybox

ScanMyPhotos and Legacybox share much in common: both provide an easy strategy for scanning photos. Both also promise to make physical media available in a digital format.

 

That being said, there are a few major differences. From formats to timelines and even photo quality, there's a lot to consider. We'll break down all the details below:

 

Photo Scanning Quality

As you consider scanning quality, look at metrics such as dots per inch (DPI). ScanMyPhotos offers multiple resolution options, including one categorized as "archival" (300 DPI) and another deemed professional quality (600 DPI). Typically, a higher DPI leads to a higher quality image. With ScanMyPhotos, choosing a higher DPI comes with a higher price tag.

 

Legacybox takes another approach, making the most of high-resolution images but also focusing on preservation. With Legacybox, the ultimate goal is to keep old photos looking their best. Legacybox's highly trained technicians are true digitizing experts — and they know what it takes to deliver a quality conversion.

 

Services & Features

As its name suggests, ScanMyPhotos focuses on bulk photo scanning with boxes and pay-per-photo options available. ScanMyPhotos also offers a few other services, like digital negative scanning, a small selection of film transfers, including VHS, and photo restoration.

 

Legacybox offers a wider range of digitizing services. Yes, photo scanning is important, but Legacybox tackles many other types of media: VHS tapes, Digital8, Betamax, Super8, audio cassettes, and beyond.

 

Better yet, versatile Legacybox kits make it easy to mix and match different types of media. Versatility is the name of the game and, no matter which types of media you want to convert, you can feel confident that Legacybox will help.

 

Turnaround Time

It takes time to scan photos, especially when dealing with large batches or scanning at high resolutions. Many people are happy to wait a few weeks to ensure quality scans, but some situations call for faster service.

 

When tight deadlines take over, solutions such as ScanMyPhotos may seem appealing, with turnaround times spanning between two and four weeks. Same-day Xpress ScanFast services pick up the pace, digitizing photos the day they arrive.

 

A fast turnaround time may seem great but with a major caveat: quick scans are not necessarily high-quality scans. Unfortunately, the techniques and resolutions that expedite scanning may also lead to lower-quality images.

 

With Legacybox, the full cycle lasts between ten and twelve weeks. This accounts for the time needed to ship to the Legacybox facility and the attentive work of skilled technicians, who digitize every item by hand. Expedited and rush services are available for an additional fee.

 

Shipping & Security

Both ScanMyPhotos and Legacybox offer kits to simplify the shipping process. With ScanMyPhotos, these are known simply as boxes. The process is simple: receive a prepaid box, pack it with photos, and send it to the ScanMyPhotos facility in Irvine. The Legacybox approach is similar, but involves mixed-and-matched kits that can contain several types of media: photos, VHS, and more.

 

Security matters and this is where differences between ScanMyPhotos and Legacybox come into play. Digitizing with ScanMyPhotos means relying on FedEx or USPS Priority Mail. Legacybox promises elevated security, complete with safety barcodes that help keep you in the loop every step of the way.

 

Pricing & Value

Digitization services need not break the bank. This is an investment worth making — and done right, it can be surprisingly affordable. The only problem? Pricing can sometimes be difficult to understand.

 

With ScanMyPhotos, costs are shaped by many factors: DPI, boxes versus pay-per-photo, thumb drive access, and restorations. Be prepared: prices can quickly increase as you complete the ordering process.

 

Legacybox may seem more expensive at first glance, but promises transparent and easy-to-understand pricing. Skip the confusion with an all-inclusive approach. Kits are priced by size, with a few simple and reasonable add-ons available: rush service, cloud renewals, or thumb drive access.

 

Customer Reviews

Strong customer reviews can help you feel confident in your decision. You'll be pleased to discover that, overall, both ScanMyPhotos and Legacybox customers are happy with their photo scanning results.

 

ScanMyPhotos customers tend to comment on the quick turnaround times, but some are concerned about the quality. With Legacybox, however, quality is a high point. Customers also praise Legacybox's ease of use and security.

 

Final Verdict: Why Legacybox is the Better Choice

There are many ways to get your media digitized. This is great news — different services appeal to different people, and thankfully, there is something for everyone. You should have no trouble reaching your end goal of beautifully preserved media.

 

As you explore options such as ScanMyPhotos and Legacybox, consider your own unique priorities. If you are focused on quality or versatility, Legacybox may be the better option. In addition to pristine photo scans, you can expect high-quality digitizing for all your old media: tapes, reels, cassettes, and more. Feel free to mix and match as you pack your curated Legacybox kit.

 

Ready to take the next step? Learn more about Legacybox's services and our easy-to-navigate process. Feel free to explore our photo scanning services and digitizing kits — you'll thank yourself for working with the best in the media digitization business.

Continue Reading
iMemories Reviews: Uncovering the Pros and Cons
iMemories Reviews: Uncovering the Pros and Cons
Forever Studios Reviews—How They Compare to Legacybox
Forever Studios Reviews—How They Compare to Legacybox
Introducing Legacybox’s New Cloud Storage: Secure, Convenient, and Accessible
Introducing Legacybox’s New Cloud Storage: Secure, Convenient, and Accessible
Our Favorite Throwback Products
Legacybox Media Conversion Kit. Shop Now>
Impossible Polaroid SX-70 Original Instant Film Camera
Victrola VBB-10-SLV Boombox with Cassette Player
Three Ways to Become the Family Hero
Digitally Preserve your Legacy. Shop Now>
Make a Highlight Reel
Enjoy a Trip Down Memory Lane
Three Ways to get Organized
Digitally Preserve your Legacy. Shop Now>
Repurpose Old Items
Condense the Clutter
Advertisement